Using Data in Nonprofit Storytelling

A Start-up Guide to Building Useful Program Evaluation

In the dynamic landscape of nonprofits, leveraging data to craft compelling narratives is critical. However, many organizations struggle to navigate nonprofit storytelling and the use program evaluation effectively. This guide serves as a start-up manual to demystifying program evaluation and harnessing its power to tell your story with impact.

The Power of Data in Nonprofit Storytelling

Data has become an indispensable asset in today’s world, providing a foundation for making informed decisions, demonstrating impact, and securing funding. For nonprofits, using data to tell your story isn’t just about numbers; it’s about weaving those numbers into a narrative that resonates with stakeholders. Whether you aim to ignite revenue growth, cultivate a devoted fanbase, or foster a vibrant organizational culture, strategic data utilization can propel your organization forward.

Demystifying Program Evaluation

What is Program Evaluation?

Program evaluation is a systematic method for collecting, analyzing, and using information to answer questions about projects, policies, and programs, particularly about their effectiveness and efficiency. It helps organizations understand what works, what doesn’t, and why, providing a basis for improving and refining program activities.

Why is Program Evaluation Important?

  • Accountability: Demonstrates the effectiveness of your programs to funders, stakeholders, and the community.
  • Learning and Improvement: Identifies what’s working and what needs adjustment.
  • Strategic Decision-Making: Provides data-driven insights that guide future initiatives.
  • Communication: Creates a narrative that can be shared with a broader audience to illustrate your impact.

Steps to Building a Program Evaluation Strategy

  1. Define Your Objectives
    Begin by clearly articulating the goals of your program evaluation. What do you hope to achieve? What questions do you want to answer? Having a clear purpose will guide your data collection and analysis efforts.
  2. Identify Relevant Data Points
    Determine what data is necessary to evaluate your program’s success. This might include quantitative data (e.g., number of participants, outcomes achieved) and qualitative data (e.g., participant feedback, case studies). The key is to focus on data that aligns with your objectives and tells a comprehensive story.
  3. Choose the Right Evaluation Methods
    Select evaluation methods that are appropriate for your data and objectives. Common methods include surveys, interviews, focus groups, and observational studies. Combining different methods can provide a more holistic view of your program’s impact.
  4. Collect and Analyze Data
    Gather the data using your chosen methods, ensuring that the process is systematic and consistent. Once collected, analyze the data to identify patterns, trends, and insights. Use statistical tools and software as needed to assist in this process.
  5. Interpret and Share Your Findings
    Interpret the data in the context of your objectives and the story you want to tell. Create reports, visualizations, and presentations that make the data accessible and engaging. Share your findings with stakeholders, using the data to illustrate the impact and value of your programs.

Using Program Evaluation in Nonprofit Storytelling

Crafting Your Narrative

Program evaluation provides the raw material for powerful nonprofit storytelling. Here’s how you can use it effectively:

  • Identify Key Messages: Based on your evaluation, determine the core messages you want to communicate. These should highlight your program’s successes, challenges, and the lessons learned.
  • Create Compelling Stories: Use data to tell stories that resonate with your audience. For instance, combine quantitative results with qualitative anecdotes. Highlight individual success stories that illustrate the broader impact of your program.
  • Visualize Your Data: People respond well to visual information. Use charts, graphs, infographics, and videos to make your data more accessible and engaging. Visuals can help translate complex data into easily understandable and memorable content.
  • Tailor Your Communication: Different stakeholders have different interests and levels of expertise. Customize your communication to fit the needs of various audiences, such as funders, community members, or policy-makers.

Practical Tips for Effective Nonprofit Storytelling

  • Be Authentic: Authenticity builds trust. Share both the triumphs and the trials, providing a balanced view of your program’s journey.
  • Focus on Impact: Highlight the real-world changes and benefits resulting from your program. Show how your work makes a difference in the community.
  • Use Testimonials: Include quotes and stories from beneficiaries, volunteers, and staff. Personal accounts add a human touch to your data.
  • Engage with Multimedia: Utilize videos, podcasts, and social media to reach a wider audience and make your stories more dynamic.


Using data to in your nonprofit storytelling is a powerful way to demonstrate your organization’s impact and drive growth. By demystifying program evaluation and adopting a strategic approach, you can unlock the potential of data to create compelling narratives that resonate with stakeholders. Start small, engage your team, and build a robust evaluation strategy that propels your organization toward success

Have more questions? Reach out, or join us an an upcoming conference.